CENTRAL NEW YORK PROGRESSIVE – SPECIAL ISSUE
In this issue, we focus on the struggle to win a fair wage for New York. In the first article, we let our readers know of the importance of attending a news conference to show support for Governor Cuomo’s proposal to raise the wage. Readers are advised to contact their state legislators as soon as possible to ask them to support working people. The second article debunks myths about increasing the minimum wage.
News Conference to Support Minimum Wage Increase Friday at 10 a.m.
Local groups including the Central New York Labor Council and Central NY Citizens in Action will be holding an important news conference this Friday morning to support the $15 minimum wage proposal. Please do your best to attend. The news conference, which will start at 10:00 a.m. on Friday, March 25, will be held at the offices of the Central New York Labor Council, 287 Genesee St., Utica, NY 13501. Please arrive at 9:45 a.m. Please let us know if we can list your group as a co-sponsor.
Some legislative leaders are talking about weakening a $15 minimum wage proposal that would make sure 3 million people across New York can afford to pay for the basics like food, housing and transportation.
There’s still time for the State Senate and Assembly to back a strong minimum wage that gets the whole state to $15, and gets there quickly. But time is running out. business lobbyists are working overtime to influence the legislature and weaken the wage increase. They’re using the same scare tactics that we see used every time a minimum wage increase is debated.
Please call your state legislator and ask them to pass the $15 minimum wage proposal.
Thank you for your support.
Community Coalition Calls on NYS Legislature to pass the $15 minimum wage by April 1.
Groups Release Report Showing Positive Impact on Upstate NY Economy
A coalition of community, labor, and public interest groups, along with concerned Central New Yorkers and local workers, will be releasing a report at a news conference showing the positive impact of passing Governor Cuomo’s proposal for a $15 statewide minimum wage will have on Central New York families and the local economies. Leaders will ask Senator Griffo and local legislators to support Governor Cuomo’s proposal to gradually phase in the $15 minimum wage by the end of 2018 in New York City and by mid-2021 in the rest of the state.
The news conference, which will start at 10:00 a.m. on Friday, March 25, will be held at the offices of the Central New York Labor Council, 287 Genesee St., Utica, NY 13501.
WHO: Event sponsored by the Central New York Citizens in Action, Inc., Central New York Labor Council, Utica Activist Coalition, Mohawk Valley Freedom School, IWW, Love and Rage, Citizen Action of New York, Working Families Party, and other local, state, and national groups
WHAT: Groups will ask the State Senate and Assembly to back the Governor Cuomo’s proposal for a phased-in increase in the minimum wage. They will also release a report detailing its positive impact of the on Central New York jobs, farms, businesses, and economy.
WHERE: Central New York Labor Council, 287 Genesee St., Utica, NY 13501 (Corner of Genesee Street and Dakin Street, Downtown Utica, near Utica Public Library); parking in the rear of the building off Dakin Street, please use rear entrance
WHEN: 10:00 a.m. Friday, March 25
Please bring signs and banners.
Tell your legislator: We need $15 NOW!
Last Tuesday, local residents joined thousands of working New Yorkers from across the state up in Albany to send a clear message to the Senate Republicans: we need $15 now and nothing less! 
Tell our legislators to pass a livable minimum wage in this year’s budget – the deadline is March 31!
The Fight for $15 is simple: No individual – and definitely no parent raising a child – can live on $9 an hour, New York’s minimum wage today. And no one who works hard every day should have to struggle to make ends meet. But that’s exactly what over 3 million people in New York who earn less than $15 an hour are forced to do. It isn’t right and it has to stop.
This year, we have a historic opportunity to take our economy back from poverty wage jobs – and the billionaire CEOs who have kept those wages low for decades – by passing a statewide $15 minimum wage.
$15 doesn’t just mean a better quality of life for hard-working people, it means we can build thriving communities. That’s because $15 will put more money in the pockets of the very people our economy depends on: Workers who’ll spend their wage increase at businesses right here in our community.
Last year, the State Legislature failed to pass a $15 minimum wage. But we can’t let another year go by without a wage that boosts working families and our economy.
We can build communities based on decent-paying jobs.
We have a historic opportunity this year, and we won’t let anyone stand in our way: Fight for $15!
Assemblyman Bill Magee, D-Nelson, 214 Farrier Ave., Oneida, N.Y. 13421; phone: 361-4125; fax: 361-4222; email: firstname.lastname@example.org
· Assemblyman Marc Butler, R-Newport, 235 N. Prospect St., Suite 101, Herkimer, N.Y. 13350; phone: 866-1632; fax: 866-5058; email: email@example.com
· Assemblywoman Claudia Tenney, R-New Hartford, 5176 St. Route 233, PO Box 597, Westmoreland, NY 13490; phone: 853-2383; fax: 853-2386; email: firstname.lastname@example.org
· Assemblyman Anthony Brindisi, D-Utica, Room 401, State Office Building, 207 Genesee St., Utica, N.Y. 13501; phone: 732-1055; fax: 732-1413; email: email@example.com
· Sen. Joseph Griffo, R-Rome, State Office Building, 207 Genesee St., Utica, N.Y. 13501; phone: 793-9072; fax: 793-0298; email: firstname.lastname@example.org
· Sen. David J. Valesky, D-Oneida, 805 State Office Building, 333 East Washington St., Syracuse, N.Y. 13202; phone: 478-8745; fax: 474-3804; email: email@example.com
· Sen. James Seward, R-Milford, 235 N. Prospect St., Herkimer, N.Y. 13350; phone: 866-1632; fax: 866-5058; email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Myth vs. Fact on a $15 Minimum Wage
for New York
Myth: There would be few benefits to a $15 minimum wage.
Fact: The benefits of gradually phasing in a $15 minimum wage for New York’s workers would be far-reaching, according to analysis by the Economic Policy Institute.
3.1 million workers – about 36% of all workers in the state – would receive raises. 1.4 million would be in New York City, and 1.7 million elsewhere in the state.
The typical worker would receive roughly a $4,800 per year raise – going a long way towards rebalancing wages in the state.
Myth: The workers earning low-wages are mostly teens in entry-level jobs who don’t need to earn a living wage.
Fact: The typical worker earning less than $15 in New York is a woman over 25 with some college-level coursework who works full-time and provides on average half of her household’s income, according to analysis by the Economic Policy Institute.
Just 5.3 percent of affected workers are teenagers. More than three-quarters are 25 or older.
52.7 percent are women.
Statewide, roughly half are persons of color. Within New York City, more than three-quarters are persons of color, and statewide, workers of color would benefit disproportionately from the increase. More than half of all Latino workers would receive a raise, and 40% of African American workers.
The workers who would benefit earn, on average, half of their family’s total income. More than a quarter (27 percent) of affected workers are the sole providers of their family’s income.
Of workers who would receive a raise, two-thirds work full time.
52.1 percent have some college experience. 19.8% have bachelor’s degrees and 9.4 have associate’s degrees.
32.9 percent have children.
Myth: Employers cannot adjust to a gradually phased in $15 minimum wage.
Fact: While business lobbyists like the New York State Business Council argue that New York employers cannot adjust to a $15 minimum wage by 2021, growing numbers of employers say that it will be manageable.
A growing list of businesses voices are supporting Governor Cuomo’s $15 minimum wage proposal. These supporters include trade associations like the Greater New York Chamber of Commerce and the Long Island African-American Chamber of Commerce, as well as individual employers like Amalgamated Bank and Ben and Jerry’s.
Moreover, the president and CEO of the Retail Council of New York State — the trade association representing New York State’s single largest low-wage industry in which 550,000 of the state’s 3.1 million workers earning less than $15 work – has joined the Governor’s $15 minimum wage campaign as a campaign vice-chair (although the Retail Council has not yet endorsed a specific proposal). The fact that this major trade group is not opposing Governor Cuomo’s proposal and its leader is serving as vice-chair of the campaign highlights the significant business support the proposal enjoys.
A diverse range of business leaders confirm that transitioning to a $15 minimum wage is entirely feasible. “’Everybody in retail is dealing with an increase in minimum wage,’ said Popeyes CEO Cheryl Bachelder to CNN Money. ‘We will adjust to increased costs just like we have before. Life will go on. There’s been too much hubbub about it.’”
Marcus Samuelsson, owner of Harlem’s Red Rooster restaurant, put it this way to Crain’s last month, “You have to adjust. I have 160 employees—we adjusted to the health care law, and we will have to adjust to [a $15 minimum wage]. As a small-business owner, I know that change is something that comes constantly.”
As Rochester-based restaurant owner Dennis Kessler who teaches at the University of Rochester’s Simon School of Business told the Washington Post last year, “This $15 thing is being phased in over quite a few years, so I don’t think it’s going to have much of an impact. . . . People are going to have to pay a little more. It really isn’t too much more complicated than that.”
Myth: $15 is an excessive minimum wage for New York, especially upstate where living costs are lower.
Fact: Cost of living data shows that even in the least expensive regions of upstate New York, a single worker will need $15 or more by 2021 just to cover the basics – and workers downstate and workers supporting children will need even more.
For example, in Buffalo, Rochester and Syracuse – which are among the least expensive places to live in New York State – a single worker will by 2021 need $32,689 in Buffalo, $33,535 in Rochester, and $33,791 in Syracuse just to cover basic living costs at a modest level. These living costs mean that a single, full-time worker will need to earn at least $15.72 per hour in Buffalo, $16.12 in Rochester and $16.25 in Syracuse by 2021 just to cover the basics.
Myth: Economists believe that a $15 minimum wage is too high for New York.
Fact: In reality, more than 200 economists have endorsed a $15 federal minimum wage by 2020, finding that raising the minimum to $15 an hour “will be an effective means of improving living standards for low-wage workers and their families and will help stabilize the economy. The costs to other groups in society will be modest and readily absorbed.”
As Nobel prize-winning economist Paul Krugman explained in a recent address at the City University of New York that “there’s absolutely no reason to think that a fifteen dollar minimum wage will be a problem for New York.”
Two careful studies – one by researchers at the University of Massachusetts9 and a second by researchers at the Purdue School of Hospitality and Tourism Management10 – both show that fast food restaurants will be able to accommodate a $15 minimum wage through significant savings from reduced staff turnover and small price increases not much greater than recent experience.
Other New York economists such as Tom Michl of Colgate University and Christopher Gunn of Hobart and William Smith Colleges have similarly endorsed a $15 minimum wage as manageable and good for the state’s economy.
Myth: Research shows that increasing the minimum wage will lead to significant job losses, and so will hurt rather than help New York’s workforce.
Fact: The bulk of rigorous minimum wage studies show that raising the minimum wage boosts incomes for low-wage workers with only very small adverse impacts on employment.
As Bloomberg News summarized it, “[a] wave of new economic research is disproving those arguments about job losses and youth employment. Previous studies tended not to control for regional economic trends that were already affecting employment levels, such as a manufacturing-dependent state that was shedding jobs. The new research looks at micro-level employment patterns for a more accurate employment picture. The studies find minimum-wage increases even provide an economic boost, albeit a small one, as strapped workers immediately spend their raises.”
This is best illustrated by “meta-studies” that survey and aggregate the findings of scores of minimum wage studies. The two leading meta-studies—by economists Hristos Doucouliagos and T.D. Stanley (2009) and Dale Belman and Paul Wolfson (2014)14 — show that the vast majority of recent studies find minimum wage increases have little to no effect on employment levels or job growth.
Analyses by opponents such as the Empire Center and American Action Forum projecting significant job losses from a $15 minimum wage are not reliable because they use outdated research methods that produce inaccurate results.
The studies they rely on claim that small minimum wage increases, like the ones NY approved in 2006 and 2013, have killed lots of jobs. But the overwhelming majority of credible studies have concluded that any adverse impacts have been very, very small.
As Crain’s New York Business has reported, “The most credible recent research shows very little loss of jobs. Nor does it show worrisome price hikes.”
Myth: Even if more moderate minimum wage increases do not lead to significant job losses, a $15 minimum wage would be too much and would hurt workers and the state economy.
Fact: Some of the most respected economists in the country disagree.
State-of-the-art modeling of the impact of a $15 minimum wage conducted by University of California economists under contract with the City of Los Angeles found that, if phased in gradually over five years, a $15 wage would be manageable for employers and would raise business operating costs just 0.9 percent by 2019.
The University of California analysis found that a phased-in $15 minimum wage would increase business operating costs and prices — but that that negative impact on business would be offset by increased spending by workers receiving higher wages. Any net negative impact on jobs would be very small.
For workers, the analysis found that the benefits would be far reaching, raising pay for approximately 41 percent of the city’s workforce and delivering an average raise of nearly $5,000 per worker per year (in 2014 dollars).
Myth: In places like Seattle, which have passed $15 minimum wage increases, businesses have started to close.
Fact: The experiences of the first jurisdictions phasing their minimum wages up to $15 have been positive. In Seattle, the first major city to adopt a $15 wage, the region’s unemployment rate hit an eight-year low of 3.6 % in August 2015, significantly lower that the state unemployment rate of 5.3 percent, following the initial wage increase in April. In a front-page story titled “Apocalypse Not: $15 and the Cuts that Never Came,” the Puget Sound Business Journal reported on “The minimum wage meltdown that never happened,” explaining that Seattle’s restaurant industry has continued to expand and thrive as the $15 wage phases in.20 King County, where Seattle is located, is on track to break last year’s record for the number of business permits issued to food service establishments. And business owners who had publicly opposed the $15 minimum wage are in the process of expanding operations.
Myth: A $15 minimum wage for New York would far higher than past minimum wages in New York or other U.S. states by any standard of comparison.
Fact: In reality, a $15 minimum wage is not that high for New York, given the state’s high cost of living, higher-than-national wages, and decades of productivity growth.
For example, if New York’s 1970 minimum wage is updated to reflect both national price changes and the higher-than-national cost of living growth in New York, it would translate to $15.01 by 2018.21
Or updating New York’s 1970 minimum wage to reflect average worker productivity growth since then, it would translate to $21.40 today. Raising the minimum wage to $15 would ensure that workers share more of the benefits of that growth.
Using another benchmark that is sometimes used to compare minimum wages – the minimum wage as a percentage of the median wage for a full-time worker, known as the “Kaitz Index” – a $15 wage in 2021 would translate to 58% of New York’s median wage. That’s just slightly higher than the U.S. minimum wage was in 1968, when it was 55% of the median wage – a period when the nation enjoyed low unemployment and strong growth.
In fact, more than half a dozen U.S. states have had minimum wages at higher levels, as compared to their median wages: 62% in Florida and Vermont; 63% in Maine and South Dakota; 66% in Mississippi and 67% in Arkansas. There is no evidence that these minimum wage levels were excessive or cost significant numbers of jobs.
Note that economists use full time, full year worker median wages as the benchmark for comparing minimum wage levels historically among the U.S. states and internationally. Opponents of Governor Cuomo’s $15 wage proposal like the Empire Center have instead been using non-full-time median wage statistics, which are not those commonly used by economists, and which do not allow for historic comparisons with minimum wage levels in the U.S. in the past.
Myth: A $15 minimum wage would give New York a higher minimum wage than other comparable developed countries.
Fact: Other developed countries like Germany, France and New Zealand already have minimum wages comparable to or higher than the proposed $15 New York minimum wage, and the U.K. is now phasing its minimum wage up to an even higher level.
A $15 minimum wage for New York, translating to 58% of the median full time wage, would be comparable to the minimum wages today in other OECD countries like France (61%), New Zealand (60%) and Germany (58%).
Moreover, the U.K. is in the process of phasing its minimum wage up to the 65% level by 2020 under the Conservative Government’s new National Living Wage (which applies to workers ages 25 and older).
Comparing international minimum wages using current exchange rates, Australia’s minimum wage will be at least $15 U.S. by 2017 – and the country hasn’t had a recession in twenty years.
Myth: A $15 minimum wage would be unsustainable for New York’s small businesses.
Fact: New York’s and other localities’ past experience with minimum wage increases do not show a disadvantage to small businesses, and in fact, the increases level the playing field for small businesses, who have to compete with large businesses for the most talented employees.
In reality it is large companies, not mom-and-pop businesses, which employ most workers in New York earning less than $15.
Most small businesses are service industry firms like dry cleaners, bodegas and diners that serve local customers. When the minimum wage goes up, they and their competitors are all on the same playing field and can gradually adjust their prices to cover the cost without being put at a disadvantage.
New York’s experiences with past minimum wage increases, and the recent experiences in cities like San Francisco, San Jose and Seattle with significant minimum wage increases, bear this out. There is no evidence that transitioning to higher wages have hurt small businesses or changed the mix of large and small businesses.
That’s why growing numbers of individual small business owners and trade groups representing small businesses like the Greater New York Chamber of Commerce and the Long Island African American Chamber of Commerce are endorsing the $15 minimum wage.
Myth: A $15 minimum wage will cost the state and taxpayers a lot.
Fact: In reality it is low wages that are generating significant public costs for the New York taxpayers.
The state’s current low minimum wage means that hundreds of thousands of the 3.2 million New Yorkers whose employers pay them less than $15 per hour must rely on state safety net programs to get by. The resulting cost to taxpayers is $9.1 billion per year – with state and local government in New York paying $2.9 billion of that cost, according to a University of California analysis.
As a result, raising the minimum wage will save the state budget significant amounts in safety net expenditures. The largest savings come from the Medicaid program, where raising the minimum wage shifts many workers from 50% state-funded regular Medicaid health insurance onto Affordable Care Act (ACA) expansion Medicaid and the ACA exchanges, which are largely federally funded. In California, it is projected that a $13 minimum wage would save the state budget over $2 billion.
A recent Urban Institute report analyzed several policy options for reducing poverty in New York City and estimated the net fiscal savings (resulting from decreased need for public assistance and increased income and payroll tax payments) to all levels of government from an increase in the minimum wage to $15. The authors concluded that the dollar amount of the net fiscal savings was equal to 43 percent of the rise in workers’ aggregate earnings as a result of the minimum wage increase.
Such savings should, as discussed below, be used to help state-contracted human services programs cover the cost of transitioning to higher wages.
Myth: Human services agencies operating under grants from state government will have to lay workers off because they cannot afford to pay $15 per hour.
Fact: It is true that the state’s human services programs – many of which are operated by non-profit organizations with contract or Medicaid funding from state government to provide early childhood education, and to care for vulnerable children, the elderly, and the developmentally disabled – will need additional funding from the state to transition to a $15 minimum wage.
Unlike for-profit businesses, the non-profit organizations operating these programs cannot raise prices to help cover the cost of raising wages since they don’t charge for these essential public services. While these services are funded by government, for many years state support has not kept up with rising costs.
Women make up 82 percent of this workforce, which generally is highly educated and half persons of color. More than half are paid less than $15 an hour in jobs long under-valued despite the fact that many of these services allow clients to function better on their own, saving taxpayers millions of dollars each year.
The state will need to increase funding for contracts to non-profits or raise Medicaid reimbursement rates to help non-profit providers transition their wages up to $15.
Fortunately, the $15 minimum wage will generate significant budgetary savings, which the legislature should use, together with new appropriated funds, to finance this important investment. Such an investment will also improve the quality of human services provided in the state, as higher wages reduce the high employee turnover, which currently plagues these programs.
Myth: Raising the minimum wage to $15 will not help workers, since they will lose significant amounts of government benefits leaving them little better off than they were before.
Fact: The major safety net benefits that most of New York’s low-wage workers receive incorporate gradual phase-outs. This means that workers are always net significantly better off for each additional dollar that they earn.
Source: Fiscal Policy Institute
Central New York Citizens in Action, Inc.
Mailing Address: P.O. Box 411; Utica, NY 13503-0411
Office: 500 Plant St.; Utica, NY 13502-4710
Central New York Citizens in Action, Inc. was developed from the Utica Citizens in Action, a multi-issue public interest association affiliated with Citizen Action of New York. It was founded in 1997 to address critical social, economic and environmental issues facing residents of Oneida, Herkimer, and Madison Counties. Members of our group worked to empower low and moderate income Central New York residents to participate in shaping the policies that affect their lives, such as economic justice, environment, housing, education, economic development, health care, public benefit programs, and consumer issues. Our projects include research and policy development, public education on a wide range of public policy issues, development of educational materials, community outreach and grassroots organizing, coalition development, training, and lobbying. Please join our email list by sending an email to email@example.com with the subject heading – Join List. We also invite you to become a member of our group and attend our meetings.